Groundwater is a precious gift of nature and is being used for drinking, agricultural, industrial, livestock. In Punjab province of Pakistan groundwater is contributing about fifty percent towards irrigation water requirements where a large aquifer underlying the Indus River Basin (IRB) is being depleted rapidly. In the present research a methodology/criterion has been developed and applied for identification of the suitable sites for recharging the aquifer artificially in the Punjab province in Pakistan. Major activities carried out include the installation of exploratory boreholes, collection and analysis of soil and water samples, determination of aquifer parameter (hydraulic conductivity) in laboratory. Other field observations include observation of groundwater levels, land availability, water availability, and physiographic features. On the basis of field surveys and laboratory investigations, criteria for identification of potential sites for artificial recharge to augment the groundwater reservoir has been developed. Keeping in view the parameters adopted in the criteria, thirteen potential sites in the critical areas have been identified for artificial recharge to replenish the depleting groundwater levels. This research provides guidelines for the decision-makers for future investment for sustainable groundwater management.
Keywords: Groundwater, Artificial recharge, Aquifer, Lithology, Rainfall, Indus-River-Basin, Punjab, Pakistan.
Citation | Ghulam Zakir-Hassan; Jehangir F Punthakey; Faiz Raza Hassan; Ghulam Shabir (2022). Methodology for Identification of Potential Sites for Artificial Groundwater Recharge in Punjab Province of Pakistan. Canadian Journal of Agriculture and Crops, 7(2): 46-77.
Copyright: © 2022 by the authors. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Funding : This study received no specific financial support.
Competing Interests: The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
History : Received: 2 May 2022 / Revised: 10 June 2022 / Accepted: 24 June 2022 / Published: 7 July 2022.
Publisher: Online Science Publishing
Highlights of this paper
Water is an essential commodity for existence of life on planet. An assured supply of wholesome water has, therefore, been the prime concern of all societies . In our own time the increasing stress on the supportive and assimilative capacities of water systems has led to a growing realization that it is only through a scientific approach to their management that we can hope to sustain the quality and regular availability of this basic human requirement. The need for appropriate integrated studies in developing countries is all the more important in view of an increasing population, widespread aridity and scarcity of fiscal resources, and changing hydro-meteorological conditions. Groundwater, surface water and land comprise a complex interlocked system and they must be considered and managed in their totality towards making the most optimal use of this precious resource. With the advent of remote sensing and sophisticated data processing techniques, the speed and scale of investigations of visible resources such as land and surface water have greatly improved. An understanding of the invisible groundwater regimes and quantification of their characteristic parameters, however, continue to remain mostly inferential and indirect. Groundwater resources are now being increasingly tapped to meet societal needs on account of their possible availability in the vicinity of the consumer. However, it is important to recognize that although groundwater has ubiquitous occurrence and vast magnitude, its potential as a perennial source is subject to wide spatio-temporal variations. It is renewable but not inexhaustible. It is underground but not entirely protected from pollution .
As indicated by many researchers and scientists, serious water scarcity situation may occur in Pakistan and the country may suffer badly, if necessary, measures are not taken from today for the management of water resources . Since last many years, rapid increase in population has resulted in over extraction of ground water especially in the urban areas to meet with human demands due to which underground watertable is depleting at alarming rates . Also in rural areas, surface water is insufficient to meet with the demands of agriculture sector due to continuous increase in food and fiber requirements. It is worth mentioning that groundwater is contributing about 40% of total water being used for irrigation purposes in the Province, while almost 100% demands for drinking water are being met from groundwater . The un-planned pumpage of groundwater is also causing salt-water intrusion into fresh groundwater due to which sweet groundwater resource is becoming scarce . This needs formulation of long term policy framework and comprehensive planning to guard against fast depleting ground water resources .
This critical situation needs to be addressed for our future generation and country’s economic growth. During monsoon rains, when lands are generally saturated and need no canal irrigation, the surplus canal water can be injected into aquifer after necessary de-silting and treatment. The rainfall water in suitable depressions and natural drains can also be used for recharging purpose. Realizing the intensity of problem, the IRI conducted research studies on artificial recharge of groundwater aquifer funded by the Provincial Government under annual development program .
It is a great misfortune that a significant volume of precious surface water annually flows down to sea due to insufficient number of large dams for storage of surplus [9, 10]. On the other hand, more than one million tube wells are extracting groundwater on continuous basis. The rate of natural re-charging (approx. 30 MAF annually) is lower than the rate of extraction (50 to 55 MAF annually) . This situation has resulted in tremendous depletion of groundwater levels; for example, in Lahore, where more than 425 tubewells are extracting about 755 Million gallon of groundwater per day for drinking purpose, while natural re-charging of groundwater aquifer is almost negligible due to construction activities and pavements of streets and roads . The only source to recharge Lahore aquifer is Ravi River which remains nearly dry except during monsoon season; the net result being that watertable in Lahore city area has depleted down to around 100 ft or even more in some cases .
The process of groundwater recharge is like refilling a leaky tank. Over the long term, recharge is generally balanced by discharge to soil surface or deeper parts of the groundwater system or by up take by plants. Natural recharge is termed as the natural process in hydrologic cycle by mean of which water from the soil surface infiltrates down and some part of it ultimately reaches the groundwater reservoir. However, this process of natural recharge is altered/affected locally by increase in impervious surfaces due to urbanization and pavement of roads/streets and other activities natural or man-made which cause changes in land use. Climate changes (e.g., less rainfall) also result in decreased in recharge of groundwater.
Groundwater is a far more important resource than is often realized. Excluding the water locked in glaciers and icecaps, about 97 percent of the World’s fresh water is groundwater while streams, rivers and lakes hold only about 3 percent .
The growing future competition for water in the Pakistan and elsewhere around the world is leading to even greater use of this enormous water resource. As part of this trend, there has been increased interest in the use of artificial recharge to augment groundwater supplies all over the world. Artificial recharge is a process by which excess surface water is injected into the ground either by direct or indirect recharging techniques by interfering with natural surface and sub-surface conditions to replenish the groundwater reservoir for its future uses.
The most common purpose of artificial recharge is to store water under ground during monsoon period to meet water demand during shortage period. Recovered recharge water is especially well-suited to non-potable uses; under appropriate conditions and where better sources are not available, recovered recharge water can also be an option for potable use. Artificial recharge can be used to control sea water intrusion in coastal aquifers, control land subsidence caused by declining groundwater levels, maintain base flow in some streams, raise groundwater levels to reduce the cost of ground water pumping, conserve or dispose the flood waters, reduce the surface drainage needs during heavy rainfalls and to maintain the groundwater quality by controlling the saline water intrusion etc.
In order to ensure that water quality remains with in permissible limits, it is important for the countries to have sufficient policies regarding recharging the aquifer. To prevent groundwater pollution, discharge from the aquifer should be regulated. While considering the disposal and storage of water into groundwater reservoir the vulnerability of the aquifer should specially be taken into account.
Dr. Nazir Ahmad, an eminent scientist has stressed on “Artificial Recharge” of Aquifer in his papers, publications and letters to IRI, WASA, PCRWR, etc. He was always much worried about Lahore aquifer. He estimated the amount of rainfall water available during Monsoon. He suggested using this water to recharge the Lahore aquifer. He pointed out that huge pumping of groundwater has lowered the watertable from a depth of 15 ft. in 1960 to a depth of 70 ft. in 1987, with the increase of Lahore population the watertable will further lower to the depth of about 90 ft. within 20 years. He also indicated the presence of inferior ground water at 19 Km away in the South of Lahore near Raiwind. It is worthwhile to check the inflow of this inferior water towards a depression of more than 70 ft. He suggested i) to install electrical gadgets at suitable sites and depth to determine the amount of saline water and ii) to estimate by numerical modeling, the optimum sites of recharge, future decline in groundwater and possible intrusion of saline water into the dewatered area of Lahore.
Ahmed  pointed out that the area of Narowal, Pasrur, Chewinda receive about 32 inches summer rainfall which accumulates between Marala, Ravi, BRBD Link and in Deg Catchments. According to his point of view this water can be used to improve the groundwater levels in Lahore areas. He also suggested, particularly for Lahore aquifer, recharge for growing population of Lahore that:- i) this water can be brought through BRBD to Lahore Branch Canal and a part discharged to River Ravi for recharging the Northern part of Lahore, ii) for recharging the eastern and middle part of Lahore, it is suggested to install recharge wells along right bank of BRBD between Ravi Syphon and Badian and along both the banks of Lahore Branch Canal and iii) different types of recharging techniques can be tested in these areas due to availability of excess rainwater. He concluded that Lahore area receives about 12 to 14 inches of summer rainfall which accumulates in the depressions, which have to be pumped for its disposal. Therefore, to conserve this water; recharge wells should be installed at some selected places in Lahore.
IRI  conducted a study on artificial recharge under semi field conditions at Field Research Station Niazbeg. It was concluded that, choking of strainer is the major problem during recharging of ground water artificially by gravity well. It was suggested that water should be treated to make it free of silt and physical debris etc. before injection to groundwater storage.
Rama  worked on the possibilities of underground storage of surplus flood water in India. He described that generous rainfall during the months of July-August-September causes floods in Gangetic basin, followed by shortage of supply during dry months. The physiography and topography of the region provides a very limited scope for surface storage. There exists the possibility of storing some of the surplus run-off of the rainy season in underground reservoirs, for use during the dry period. The scheme envisages emptying the existing natural reservoirs which are normally always full, and which are likely to fill by themselves after they are emptied, without any extra engineering. The artificial part of the scheme consists in generating productive consumption, by intensive irrigation, for the large quantity of water withdrawn. The emptied reservoir is expected to absorb a part of the flood pulse also. The scheme is likely to have maximum potential in the Gangetic plain. The most promising reservoirs, meeting the above criteria, appear to be the sandy aquifers connected with the beds of seasonal streams.
Firozudding, et al.  worked on induced recharge to deep aquifer for augmenting the water supply scheme. They found that there is mounting concern regarding the problem of developing adequate water supplies to Ambala urban area as the locally available ground water supplies through tubewells will not be able to meet the growing demands. They examined the results of the studies carried out to delineate the watertable aquifer along the riverine tract of Dangri River, the geometry and the productivity of the aquifer, its capacity to hold the required amount of water and possibilities of induced recharge for the river. It is estimated that a quantity of 2.66 MCM can be pumped out from the aquifer during the dry season. The estimated induced recharge from the river to the aquifer is about 0.833 MCM during the monsoon season. A possibility of development to the extent of 7.30 MCM of the deeper aquifers occurring below 150 m depth has also been discussed as an additional source to augment the water supply. The results of their investigation showed that the highly permeable granular zones, which can act as the most favorable zone for induced recharge, occur in the area around Khelan, Babial and Kajkipur along the riverine tract of Dangri River with average saturated thickness of about 14 meters. It is suggested to construct a well field in this area, with an average discharge of 726 m /day from each well. The well field should be laid parallel to the river on its western bank at a distance of 100 m from the river keeping spacing of 300 m between two shallow tubewells of 30 m depth. The corresponding drawdown in the center of the well field is calculated to be 7.77 m. About 10986 m/day of ground water can be withdrawn during summer months which can be utilized for augmenting the water supply to Kamala urban area. It is expected that with intensive development, water levels will go down in these areas as the system tends to be in dynamic equilibrium thereby creating additional storage space for induced infiltration. It has been estimated that a quantity of 0.833 MCM can be recharged by induced infiltration during monsoon season from the Dangri River. Further augmentation of water supply to Ambala town to the tune of 7.30 MCM of water per annum can be attempted by tapping the deeper aquifers in the depth range of 150 to 450 m bgl through a well field of 10 tubewells with a pumping rate of about 2000 m /day at each well. The average catchment area is 8.5 km2 with average gross storage of 200 TCM-both with a high coefficient of variation. There are about 475 such tanks in the Sina and the Man basins where a representative study is made by selective monitoring of tank levels, contents, ground water levels in wells, and evaporation rate. Evaporation on an average account for 10. 7% of total depletion of tank contents. An average percolation rate of 45 mm/day was estimated for post monsoon period which may include the visible seepage appearing in water courses downstream. Those wells which are influenced by percolation show increased yield of 10 to 30%, by taking into consideration water levels and time factor. Some of the aspects of percolation tanks are outlined in the light of the findings. Storage changes in tanks are affected by many factors –from surface runoff of catchments areas, by direct addition from rainfall, and from groundwater appearing as effluent seepage. The decrease in storage can be accounted for as recharge to groundwater bodies evaporation, and other usage through distribution works. So far as the percolation tanks are concerned the loss in storage is entirely due to percolation and evaporation. A certain amount of groundwater may reappear as visible seepage or groundwater runoff, or different lengths of time, downstream of the tanks. The processes of evaporation and percolation are more vigorous after the withdrawal of monsoon for obvious reasons. Water stage in the tanks is recorded periodically either on the embankment slope or on the staff gauges specifically erected in the tank. Storage volumes are calculated from capacity curves of the tanks survey. Evaporation from reservoir surface is the other factor to be determined. Pan evaporation data from the nearest meteorological station were taken as representative. Tank evaporation is taken as 0.7 times of Pan evaporation rate observed.
Artificial recharge can take place through direct and indirect methods and most of the country use artificial recharge to obtain different objectives like (i) the maximization of storage (including seasonal, long-term, and drought or emergency water supplies), (ii) physical management of the aquifer, (iii) water quality management, (iv) management of water distribution systems, (v) ecological benefits. The use of recharged water may determine what method, or a combination of methods should be adopted for artificial recharge at a particular site.
Artificial groundwater recharge projects aim at augmenting the natural infiltration of precipitation or surface water into underground formations by some method of construction, spreading of water or by artificially changing natural conditions. Schemes contemplating artificial recharge as the sole objective can be planned or in the alternative artificial recharge can be realized as an objective incidental to certain other developmental programs. For instance, soil conservation practices which aim at conservation of fertile topsoil and improved agricultural practices intended to maintain proper soil structure incidentally help in reduction of surface runoff and maintain high infiltration rates and thus augment groundwater recharge.
Continuous depletion and unplanned pumping of the aquifer at many locations is posting a serious threat for economy of the country and water crisis in Pakistan. This situation has given rise to the different issues like i) uncontrolled and unregulated groundwater abstraction, ii) over depletion of groundwater reservoir, iii) deterioration of groundwater quality iv) increase in cost of installation and operation of tube wells due to decline in watertable, v) saline water intrusion and vi) secondary salinization etc. All these demands some urgent and sustainable planning and management measures to replenish the aquifer for its long-term use without environmental hazards. For this purpose, it is the need of the hour to store and avoid wastage of even a single drop of water. In urban areas natural recharge has been reduced due to urbanization and rainfall water goes waste to surface drains or enters the sewerage system and causes the problem of flooding and/or choking the disposal network during rainy seasons. This water can be diverted and injected to underground reservoir and can prove very helpful in recharging the aquifer.
Natural groundwater resources are understood to be the total amount of recharge (replenishment) of groundwater under natural conditions as a result of infiltration of precipitation, seepage from rivers and lakes, leakage from overlying and underlying aquifers, and inflow from adjacent areas. This definition has been generally accepted.
According to research studies, storing of flood water as groundwater has a number of essential advantages when compared with surface water: as a rule, it is of higher quality, better protected from possible surface pollution including infection, not subject to evaporation, less subject to seasonal and perennial fluctuations, and much more uniformly spread over large regions than surface water. Very often groundwater is available in places where there is no surface water. Putting groundwater well fields into operation can be gradual in response to growing water demand while hydrotechnical facilities for surface water use often require considerable one-time investments. The subsurface reservoir is usually of large capacity. In place of costly dams required to hold water at the surface, smaller and safer structures may suffice to hold back flood flow until it can be put underground. Water may be stored underground for use during a series of years of subnormal rainfall.
The size of available underground storage depends upon the volume of porous material between the “seasonal high” position of the watertable for the year in which storage operations are conducted and the watertable which develops due to effluent seepage. If pumping plants are so arranged that they draw down the watertable throughout the area of effluent seepage, occurred due to a high-watertable may be overcome and a large available storage space maintained throughout the year and throughout a wet cycle than under natural conditions. A coordinated plan of water storage, therefore, involves installation and operation of pumping plants.
From the legal standpoint, landowners have cause for action if their properties are damaged by a high-watertable due to artificial storage of groundwater. It has been suggested that the watertable at the end of a wet cycle of years (“cyclic high”) is the upper boundary of the groundwater reservoir and filling the reservoir to this level is permissible. Whether or not the “cyclic high” position of the watertable will be adopted by the courts remains to the seen. One can foresee numerous lawsuits from spreading operations now contemplated in southern California, and it would be advisable to study the probable effluent seepage at various watertable stages before spreading operations are initiated.
IRI  conducted a study on artificial recharge under semi field conditions and concluded that, choking of strainer is the major problem during recharging of ground water artificially by gravity well. It was suggested that water should be treated to make silt free before injection to groundwater.
Managed aquifer recharge (MAR) has become a widely being used tool for augmentation of depleting aquifer across the globe and it has many benefits as well [18, 19]. MAR models have worked successfully in many places in South Asia as well . In Punjab Pakistan, surplus rainfall and floodwater is available during the monsoon periods (June to October). This water if harvested properly and managed scientifically, can be stored in the underground storage. Research studies have indicated that rainwater is suitable for MAR is harvested properly . Sufficient storage potential is available in the aquifer underlying the Indus River Basin (IRB) in Pakistan . This study has been conducted to carry out field survey and investigations at critical (depleted) sites in the Punjab province of Pakistan. Considering the different requirements for Mar schemes a criterion has been developed to identify the potential and feasible sites for MAR schemes .
2.1. Study AreaPresent study has been carried out in the Punjab province of Pakistan as shown in Figure 1. Initially fresh data of groundwater levels and quality provided in DLR  was taken as reference. Suitable points with respect to water quality and groundwater levels were chosen for physical survey. On the basis of field surveys and investigations, potential sites for recharging the aquifer artificially had been identified. Research activities have been carried out in the province of Punjab especially in critical areas (groundwater highly depleted areas). Groundwater recharge broadly describes the replenishment of water to a groundwater flow system. Recharge, an integral part of the hydrologic cycle, is the process by which water moves to the groundwater and then away from that area though saturated materials .
Figure 1. Map of study area showing location of exploratory boreholes at investigation sites in different irrigation zones in Punjab Pakistan.
2.2. Methods of Artificial Recharge
Artificial recharge is the planned human activity for augmenting the amount of groundwater available through works designed to increase the natural replenishment of surface waters into the groundwater aquifers, resulting in a corresponding increase in the amount of groundwater available for abstraction. A variety of methods have been developed and applied to artificially recharge groundwater reservoirs in various parts of the world. Selection of the feasible methods is important and can be challenging. The methods may be generally classified as i) the direct surface recharging techniques, ii) indirect recharge techniques and iii) combination of surface and subsurface methods including subsurface drainage (collector wells), basins with pits, shafts, and wells etc. Oakford . Different methods of artificial recharge have been reviewed and their feasibility at various sites has been explored. Methods of artificial recharge have been ilustrated in the Figure 2.
2.3. Direct Methods
Artificial recharge can be accomplished through various direct methods like spreading methods, through injection wells or through pits and shafts. Spreading methods include flooding method, natural channel method etc. The local field conditions including the physiography and hydrogeology of the area have to be carefully considered before selecting a method for artificial recharge.
Direct methods can be divided into surface recharge and subsurface recharge techniques. In surface recharge, water moves from the land surface to the aquifer by means of infiltration through the soil. The surface is usually excavated, and water is added to spreading basins, ditches, pits and shafts and allowed to infiltrate. Generally, surface recharge methods are dependent on the contact time the water has with the soil. Direct surface methods, in comparison to other methods, involve low construction costs and are easy to operate and maintain. Sub-surface recharge methods include recharging the water directly to groundwater by means of recharging wells or shafts. Direct Recharge Methods are shown in Figure 3.
2.4. Indirect Methods
Indirect methods include installing groundwater pumping facilities near connected surface water bodies to lower groundwater levels and induce infiltration elsewhere in the drainage basin. Indirect methods include modifying aquifers to enhance groundwater reserves as well. Enhanced streambed infiltration is creating a system of wells near a surface water body. One line of wells is set parallel the bank of a river and a second line of wells are located a short distance from the river. Conjunctive wells are screened in both a shallow confined aquifer and a deeper artesian aquifer. Water is pumped from the deeper aquifer and if its potentiometric surface is lowered below the shallow watertable, water from the shallow aquifer drains directly.
2.5. Aquifer Storage and Recovery (ASR)
The idea behind ASR is to take water during times of surplus flows / floods, store it in a large available subsurface reservoir (aquifers), and recover water during dry times when traditional surface water supplies are not available. The watertable defines the top of the saturated part of an aquifer. The area of the aquifer above the watertable is referred as the unsaturated or vadose zone. The conventional supply source is surface water, although there are several examples where water is taken from shallow aquifers and pumped into deeper aquifers. The ideal geological formation for ASR use is a permeable / sandy aquifer that is bounded and has limited hydraulic connection to surface water. Under these conditions, water can be recharged and recovered without significant losses during the storage period. The surface water used for recharge should have low suspended solids to prevent clogging of the wells by sediment or bacterial growth.
Beyond the facilitation in permitting new water supply, ASR can provide economic benefits to the water system managers. Drinking water systems are designed to meet peak needs. The result is that costly infrastructure, such as surface water treatment plants; operate at below capacity during the off-peak season.
Expensive expansions of existing surface water treatment plants to meet projected summer demand peaks can be substituted by incorporating an ASR program. Under-utilized existing facilities can be used to provide treated water for recharge while increased peak demand can be met by recovering the recharged water from new ASR wells.
2.6. Sub-Soil Parameters
Analysis of soil samples has been carried out to obtain the soil classifications and grain size distribution below the soil surface up to the deep aquifer. The type of strata where water is to be recharged plays an important role as sandy formation will support the recharge process and vice versa. This test is performed to determine the percentage of different grain sizes contained with a soil. The mechanical or sieve analysis is performed to determine the distribution of the courser, larger sized particles and the pipette method is used to determine the distribution of the finer particles. Soil classification according to texture is usually done by means of triangular diagram  .
2.7. Sampling for Groundwater Quality
Total 60 No groundwater samples (one from each borehole location) or from nearby source were collected. Water samples were analyzed for calculating the concentration of various Cations and Anions. The sample analysis would focus on the three major conventional water quality parameters i.e., Electrical Conductivity (EC), Sodium Adsorption Ratio (SAR) and Residual Sodium Carbonate (RSC). Data and presented in Annexure A (supplementary material)
2.8. Depth to Watertable
Although basic purpose of installing the exploratory bore holes was to determine the soil classification in critical areas, observations of groundwater levels was also carried out. Groundwater levels of 60 No. exploratory boreholes have been recorded twice, one at the time of boring and 2nd during pre-monsoon (June 2009). Observations of groundwater levels from these already installed exploratory boreholes in the field during the year 2008-09 have been observed to determine the fluctuations in watertable in different irrigation zones. Some glimpses from field data observations are shown in Figures 4, 5 and 6. Data on locations addresses, depth to watertable and other features of exploratory bore holes are given in Annexures B and C (supplementary material).
3.1. Analysis of Soil Samples
Soil samples from the exploratory boreholes from depths where strata physically changed were collected at site. These were analyzed in the Soil Mechanics Laboratory of Irrigation Research Institute (IRI) to determine the soil stratification/gradation. For this purpose, Soil Triangle of ASTM has been used. The soil samples from each borehole for finding out permeability were also collected and analyzed in the laboratory. Bore logs of all 60 sites up to depth of 100 ft have been prepared being used as the baseline information for identification of potential sites. Soil samples collected from all borehole’s sites were analyzed to determine the sub-surface local lithology at a specific location and aquifer parameters to proceed further for artificially recharging the aquifer. Overall objective of the soil analysis is to determine the soil and aquifer parameters which are very vital for recharging the aquifer by some artificial method.
Name of irrigation zone
No of exploratory boreholes installed
No of soil samples collected
3.2. Groundwater Quality
The exploratory boreholes were dug in Lahore, Multan and Faisalabad Irrigation Zones of the Punjab for preliminary investigations. The groundwater samples from nearby source were collected from 58 sites for checking groundwater quality. The results of chemical analysis of these samples are given in Annexure A (supplementary material). The results indicate that out of 58 sites, groundwater water quality at 14 preliminary investigation sites is unfit for irrigation purposes and thus recharging aquifer at these sites is not economical and hence not recommended.
3.3. Criteria for Selection of Potential Sites
Initially, groundwater levels and water quality data presented in DLR  has been taken as reference for identification of low groundwater levels areas in the Punjab Province. Efforts were made to select the potential sites for conducting the experimentation on artificial recharge on the basis of some scientific reasoning. Keeping in consideration the available data, status of groundwater in the province was reviewed. General criteria for selection of potential sites for installing the exploratory boreholes were set which is given in Table 2.
On the basis of above-mentioned criteria and available data, 60 bore sites were selected for installation of exploratory bore holes for carrying out the field survey and sub-surface investigations. Location of 60 exploratory boreholes installed in Irrigation Zones of (Multan zone 9, Lahore Zone 31, and Faisalabad Zone 20) are shown in Figure 1. Subsequent analysis includes soil strata classification, soil permeability and groundwater flow pattern etc. for selection of potential sites.
|Sr. No||Parameter||General Value/Limit|
|Depth to watertable||> 30 ft|
|Groundwater Quality (EC)||˂ 1.5 ds/m|
|Average annual rain falls (min)||(Lahore: approx.16”)|
|Surface water availability||Existing|
|Ground water extraction||Intensive farmers tubewells|
|Soil strata of the area||(min. seepage rate of 10-7 cm/sec as in the medium sand strata)|
|Water catchment area||Possibly less polluted area|
|Staggering of bore hole sites||Along canals (water bodies)|
|Field area Characteristics||Depression along canals and wet land within river system|
3.4. Potential Sites for Artificial Recharge
On the basis of research and field survey work done so far, 13 potential sites as given in Table 3 and shown in Figure 12 for conducting the actual experimentation on artificial recharge of aquifer have been identified keeping in view the developed criteria outlined in Table 1. These are the potential sites where field experimentation on artificial recharge can be carried out. These are the feasible sites where future investments can be made for sustainable management of groundwater resources in the province.
|Sr. #||Name of Site||Possible Recharging Source||Geographical Coordinates|
|LAHORE ZONE (Total Bore holes 31)|
|i.||Jallo Park, Lahore.||LHR Branch/ BRBD||31.57357 N||74.46995 E|
|ii.||Along BRBD Canal Right Bank, near Barki Village, Lahore||RD 373+500/ R BRBD Canal||31.47972 N||74.50579 E|
|iii.||Padhana Village, Barki Road, Lahore (Western Side of Lake).||Rain accumulated depression||31.47519 N||74.62255 E|
|iv.||Khoo Mian Muzaffar Bodla near Chak No. 47, Pipli Pahar Road, Depalpur||Nehranwala Disty/ Khanwah Br/ BSL-I||30.65165 N||73.55589 E|
|v.||Post No. 4, Civil Aviation Authority, Southern end of Runway, Lahore International Airport, Lahore||Rain Run-Off||31.50933 N||74.40714 E|
|vi.||Walton Airport, Ferozepur Road, Lahore.||Rain Run-Off||31.48923 N||74.34890 E|
|vii.||Northern Plot of Badshahi Mosque, Lahore||Rain Run-Off||31.58960 N||74.31025 E|
|viii.||Field Research Station, Niazbeg, Multan Road, Lahore.||Roof run-off/ Canal water||31.47464 N||74.22869 E|
|MULTAN ZONE (Total bore holes 9)|
|ix||Chak Sooma, Almadina Bricks, Pakpattan||Tabar Minor/PKP Dy./ Khaddar Branch/ PC||30.35718 N||73.41048 E|
|x||Bangle Jinan Shah near Rang Shah Pull, Pakpattan||Pakpattan Canal||30.34969 N||73.14286 E|
|FAISALABAD ZONE (Total Bore holes 20)|
|xi||Govt. Primary School Saeedabad, Markiz Chiniot Janoobi
(near Kot Khuda Yar Rest House),
Tehsil & Distt. Chiniot
|Chiniot Dist/ Jhang Branch Upper/ LCC||31.66360 N||72.92997 E|
|xii||Jaura Rest House at Heads of Feeder Disty and Sultan Pakhra Disty (off-taking RD 37+600 of Bhawana Br),
Teh. Bhawana, Distt. Chiniot
|Sultan Pakhra Disty/ Bhawana Br/ JBU (T)/ LCC||31.49978 N||72.72256 E|
|xiii.||Basic Heath Unit, Chak No. 457 Kot Lakhnana, Gojra Road, Tehsil and Distt. Jhang||Khandwala Mr/ Daular Disty/ JBL/ LCC||31.23375 N||72.41833 E|
Few glimpses of potential sites identified for MAR are shown in Figures 8 to 11.
The study, which mainly deals with the preliminary activities like drilling of exploratory bore holes, collection of basic data/available records, installation of piezometers, procurement of equipments, determination of soil and aquifer characteristics, development of a criteria for selection of potential sites for artificial recharge, water availability situation, groundwater quality, depth to watertable, and finally identification of potential sites for actual experimentation on artificial recharge. Out of 60 experimental sites in different irrigation Zones of the Punjab, 13 potential sites have been identified which meet the developed criteria and suitable implementation of small-scale MAR schemes. MAR can be the potential source of augmenting the depleted aquifers at local as well as regional scale. For this purpose, rainfall harvesting and experimentation of artificial recharge on selected potential sites is urgently required. Detailed rainfall-runoff modeling for this purpose is required.
The research study has been carried out by Irrigation Research Institute (IRI) under a Provincial Government funded project. Cooperation rendered by different institutions like SMO, IWASRI, IWMI, DLR, WASA, River Survey Division, Drainage Division, Survey of Pakistan, Meteorological department etc. in provision of necessary data/information is acknowledged.
 G. Z. Hassan, F. R. Hassan, and G. Shabir, "Food security challenges under climatic changes and groundwater-energy nexus- case study of Punjab-Pakistan," presented at the 23rd International Congress on Irrigation and Drainage-ICID, 8-14 October 2017, Mexico City, Mexico, 2017.
 S. Foster, J. Chilton, G. J. Nijsten, and A. Richts, "Groundwater—a global focus on the ‘local resource," Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, vol. 5, pp. 685-695, 2013.Available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cosust.2013.10.010.
 G. Zakir-Hassan, M. A. S. Butt, G. Shabir, and S. Akhtar, "Urbanization and groundwater sustainability-A case study of Lahore Pakistan," presented at the International Conference on Urban Drainage (ICUD), 24-29 Oct 2021, Melbourne, Australia, 2021.
 B. Fatima, F. U. Hasan, M. Ashraf, and A. Ahmad, "Integrated water resources management, implementation guidelines for Pakistan: Pakistan council of research in water resources (PCRWR), Islamabad," p. 84, 2021.
 M. M. Saeed, M. Ashraf, and M. N. Asghar, "Hydraulic and hydro-salinity behavior of skimming wells under different pumping regimes," Agricultural Water Management, vol. 61, pp. 163-177, 2003.Available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0378-3774(03)00026-x.
 IRI, "Research studies on artificial recharges of aquifer in Punjab," Research Report No IRR-Phy/579, Groundwater Managment Cell, Irrigation Research Institute, Irrigation Department, Government of the Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan2013.
 WB, Stakeholder participation in groundwater management enabling and nurturing engagement; Sustainable groundwater management concepts & tools; briefing note series; Note 6, GW.Mate. USA: The World Bank, 2010.
 J. J. L. Wescoat, A. Siddiqi, and A. Muhammad, "Socio‐hydrology of channel flows in complex river basins: Rivers, canals, and distributaries in Punjab, Pakistan," Water Resources Research, vol. 54, pp. 464-479, 2018.Available at: https://doi.org/10.1002/2017wr021486.
 IRI, "Recharge of aquifer for groundwater management in Punjab (2016-2019)," Report No IRR-GWMC/121, Groundwater Management Cell, Irrigation Reserach Institute (IRI), Irrigation Department, Lahore, Pakistan2019b.
 IRI, "Model studies on development of groundwater resources of Punjab by artificial recharge methods," Research Report No IRR-Phy/538 March 1999, Irrigation Research Institute, Irrigation Department Lahore, Pakistan1999.
 Rama, "Underground storage of surplus flood waters in gangetic plain," presented at the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research Homi Bhabha Road, Bombay 40005, International Workshop on Appropriate Methodologies for Development and Management of Groundwater Resources in Developing Countries, February 28 to March 4, National Geophysical Research Institute, Hyderabad, India, 1989.
 T. G. Firozudding, G. Suryanarayana, D. S. S. Murthy, and K. V. J. R. Krupanidhi, "Possibilities of induced recharge and development of deeper aquifers for augmenting water supply to Ambala urban area," presented at the International Workshop on Appropriate Methodologies for Development and Management of Groundwater Resources in Developing Countries, February 28 to March 4, National Geophysical Research Institute, Hyderabad, India, 1989.
 P. Dahlqvist, K. Sjöstrand, A. Lindhe, L. Rosén, J. Nisell, E. Hellstrand, and B. Holgersson, "Potential benefits of managed aquifer recharge mar on the island of Gotland, Sweden," Water, vol. 11, p. 2164, 2019.Available at: https://doi.org/10.3390/w11102164.
 M. I. Hossain, M. N. Bari, S. U. Miah, C. S. Jahan, and M. F. Rahaman, "Performance of MAR model for stormwater management in Barind Tract, Bangladesh," Groundwater for Sustainable Development, vol. 10, p. 100285, 2020.Available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gsd.2019.100285.
 IRI, "Feasibility of rainfall harvesting for artificial recahrge of groundwater," Research Rport No IRR-Phy/627, Irrigation Reserach Institute (IRI), Punjab Irrigation Department, Lahore, Pakistan2019a.
 G. Zakir-Hassan, F. R. Hassan, G. Shabir, and H. Rafique, "Impact of floods on groundwater—a case study of Chaj Doab in Indus Basin of Pakistan," International Journal of Food Science and Agriculture, vol. 5, pp. 639-653, 2021.Available at: https://doi.org/10.26855/ijfsa.2021.12.011.
 IRI, Groundwater investigations for water supply to FDA-city housing scheme Faisalabad: Research report No: IRR-Phy/577. Lahore, Pakistan: Irrigation Research Institute, Irrigation Department, Govt of the Punjab, 2012.
|Sr. #||Site Description||Recharging Source/Reference||Bore Dug
|Depth to Water
(at the time
|Depth to Water Table (ft)||Depth to Water Table (ft)||Remarks|
|1||Govt. Primary School Saeedabad, Markiz Chiniot Janoobi (near Kot Khuda Yar Rest House),
Tehsil and Distt. Chiniot
|Chiniot Dist/ Jhang Branch Upper/ LCC||1||2/6/2009||47||6/7/2009||47.6||12/10/2009||47.24||19/06/2010||49.25||GW fit for irrigation|
|2||Dera Muhammad Imtiaz S/O Dost Muhammad, Chak No. 132/ JB Dhamroy, Tehsil and Distt. Chiniot||Pabbarwala Disty/ JBU/ LCC||1||3/6/2009||39||6/7/2009||40.7||12/10/2009||41.37||19/06/2010||42.89||GW fit for irrigation|
|3||Dera Mehr Ghulam Muhammad S/O Sikandar, Mauza Aidlana,
Teh. Bhawana, Distt. Chiniot
|Chiniot Dist/ JBU/ LCC||1||4/6/2009||49||6/7/2009||49.4||12/10/2009||49.83||19/06/2010||50.48||GW fit for irrigation|
|4||Dera Qasim Ali, Chak No. 138/ JB Noul, Tehsil and Distt. Chiniot||Kot Ahmad Yar Br/ Chiniot Dist/ JBU/ LCC||1||4/6/2009||47||6/7/2009||48.6||12/10/2009||49.11||19/06/2010||50.06||GW fit for irrigation|
|5||Dera Mian Ghulam Shabbir S/O Mian Noor Nabi, Mauza Barkhurdar, Gaddianwala Pull, Bhawana-Chioniot Road, Teh. Bhawana, Distt. Chiniot||Taja Berwala Minor/ Ahmad Yar Br/ Chiniot Dist/ JBU/ LCC||1||5/6/2009||50||7/7/2009||51.3||30/10/2009||52.49||19/06/2010||52.79||GW fit for irrigation|
|6||Chak No. 223/ JB (Shumali), Ramana, Bhawana - Panseera Road, Teh. Bhawana, Distt. Chiniot||Mochiwala Br. Disty/ Sultan Pakhra Disty/ Bhawana Br/ JBU (T)/ LCC||1||5/6/2009||49||7/7/2009||50.9||12/10/2009||51.74||11/6/2010||53.29||GW fit for irrigation|
|7||Veterinary Hospital, Chak No. 199/ JB Rahmoana, Teh. Bhawana, Distt. Chiniot||Nila Minor No. 1/ JBL/ LCC||1||5/6/2009||46||7/7/2009||46.7||12/10/2009||47.75||13/06/2010||Choked at 46.42||GW fit for irrigation|
|8||Dera Shamsul Haq S/O Karam Ali Sipra, Chak No. 159/ JB Wer Siprawan, Tehsil and Distt. Jhang||Maghani Disty/ Feeder Disty/ Bhawana Br/ JBU(T)/ LCC||1||6/6/2009||45||7/7/2009||45.4||30/10/2009||45.47||11/6/2010||46.75||GW fit for irrigation|
|9||Dera Ghulam Muhammad Jappa, Chak No. 196/ JB (Jeewan ka Chak) near Adilwala Rest House,
Teh. Bhawana, Distt. Chiniot
|Sultan Pakhra Disty/ Bhawana Br/ JBU (T)/ LCC||1||7/6/2009||54||7/7/2009||55.5||30/10/2009||55.9||11/6/2010||56.46||GW fit for irrigation|
|10||Dera Munshi Ghulam Akbar Bharwana, Chak No. 261/ JB Kot Humayun, Tehsil and Distt. Jhang||Sultan Pakhra Disty/ Bhawana Br/ JBU (T)/ LCC||1||7/6/2009||55||7/7/2009||56.35||30/10/2009||56.82||19/06/2010||57.67||GW fit for irrigation|
|11||Jaura Rest House at Heads of Feeder Disty and Sultan Pakhra Disty (off-taking RD 37+600 of Bhawana Br), Teh. Bhawana, Distt. Chiniot||Sultan Pakhra Disty/ Bhawana Br/ JBU (T)/ LCC||1||11/6/2009||38||6/7/2009||39.9||12/10/2009||40.06||11/6/2010||42.38||GW fit for irrigation|
|12||Dera Manzoor Hussain S/O Bahadar (Cheera), Chak No. 242/ JB, Mauza Sir Nanga, Bhawana -Panseera Road, Teh. Bhawana, Distt. Chiniot||Feeder Disty/ Bhawana Br/ JBU (T)/ LCC||1||11/6/2009||49||7/7/2009||Choked at 30 ft||12/10/2009||Choked at
|GW fit for irrigation|
|13||Dera Muhammad Yar S/O Haji Khan Muhammad Mahra (adjoining abadi), Chak No. 235/ JB Hibbuana, Bhawana Road, Teh. Bhawana, Distt. Chiniot||Hibbuana Disty/ Bhawana Br/ JBU (T)/ LCC||1||12/6/2009||35||6/7/2009||36.8||12/10/2009||37.3||11/6/2010||38.75||GW fit for irrigation|
|14||Dera Ahmad Nawaz S/O Abdullah Dehlera, Mauza Suleman Kallar Wala, Sherabad Stop, Tehsil and Distt. Jhang||Sultan Pakhra Disty/ Bhawana Br/ JBU (T)/ LCC||1||12/6/2009||51||7/7/2009||53.3||30/10/2009||52.69||13/06/2010||53.79||GW fit for irrigation|
|15||Dera Zulfiqar Bhogia, Chak No. 181 Bhogia (6 km from Gojra More), Jhang - FSD Road, Tehsil and Distt. Jhang||Balluana Mr/ Daular Disty/ JBL/ LCC||1||13/06/2009||42||7/7/2009||43||30/10/2009||43.3||13/06/2010||44.75||GW fit for irrigation|
|16||Dera Mian Saifullah S/O Ghulam Muhammad, Chak No. 269/ JB Kikranwala, Jhang - FSD Road,
Tehsil and Distt. Jhang
|Jhang Mr/ Sultan Pakhra Disty/ Bhawana Br/ JBU (T)/ LCC||1||13/06/2009||55||7/7/2009||56.9||30/10/2009||56.99||12/6/2010||57.46||GW fit for irrigation|
|17||Basic Heath Unit, Chak No.
457 Kot Lakhnana, Gojra Road, Tehsil and Distt. Jhang
|Khandwala Mr/ Daular Disty/ JBL/ LCC||1||15/06/2009||45||7/7/2009||46.1||30/10/2009||46.17||13/06/2010||40.39||GW fit for irrigation|
|18||Chak NO. 448 Hirajanwala (near Outlet NO. 63+645/ L, Daular Disty), Jhang - FSD Road, Adda Mochiwala, Tehsil and Distt. Jhang||Daular Disty/ JBL/ LCC||1||15/06/2009||30||7/7/2009||30.7||30/10/2009||30.41||13/06/2010||32.63||GW fit for irrigation|
|19||Dera Alam Zaib S/O Gohar Rehman, Nazim UC-49, Chak No. 475 Syedwala, Jhang-Toba Road,
Tehsil and Distt. Jhang
|Daular Disty/ JBL/ LCC||1||16/06/2009||40||7/7/2009||39.5||30/10/2009||39.76||20/06/2010||40.92||GW unfit for irrigation (DLR Report of
|20||Dera Tariq Javed, Mauza Lakh Badhar, Jhang - Mudduki Road, Tehsil and Distt. Jhang||Lakh Badhar Mr/ Daular Disty/ JBL/ LCC||1||16/06/2009||41||7/7/2009||41.7||30/10/2009||42.52||12/6/2010||42.58||GW unfit for irrigation (DLR Report of
|Total (FSD Zone)||20|
Online Science Publishing is not responsible or answerable for any loss, damage or liability, etc. caused in relation to/arising out of the use of the content. Any queries should be directed to the corresponding author of the article.